Date of Award
2004
Document Type
Practicum
Degree Name
Doctor of Education
Department
Doctor of Higher Education Leadership Program
Keywords
advancement fund, alumni, alumni fundraising, annual phonathon, alternative hypothesis, Carolinas College of Health Sciences, CCHS, chi-square test, contributions, current student, degrees of freedom, donors, experimental groups, faculty member, first solicitation, follow up, fundraising, fundraising goal, fundraising methods, fundraising resources, gifts, giving appeal, giving outcomes, human resources, initial request, mailed solicitation, null hypothesis, phone solicitation, pledges, probability, quasi-experimental research design, research question, second mailed solicitation, second request, second solicitation, solicitation methods, statistically significant relationship, student volunteers, written appeal, written solicitation
Abstract
The problem under investigation was that Carolinas College of Health Sciences (CCHS) had no experience in fundraising methods, limited financial and human resources to devote to fundraising, and a need to raise a substantial amount of money in a brief period of time. Determining a particularly effective technique and applying that technique would allow the college to make the most effective and efficient use of its fundraising resources, and provide the greatest number of contributions toward the fundraising goal. The purpose of the study was to determine if there was a relationship between the number of donors who contributed to the college's advancement fund upon a second request, and the type of solicitation they received. Solicitation methods being researched were second solicitations made by phone from a current student, second solicitations made by a faculty member, and a second written solicitation. The research question was: Is there a relationship between the method of second solicitation applied in alumni fundraising and the number of gifts received, when three different solicitation methods are applied?
A quasi-experimental research design was used to compare the relationship between three types of second solicitation methods and the gifts or pledges that resulted. Giving outcomes were tracked for three groups of alumni, with each group having received the identical first solicitation and a different second solicitation. All alumni in the study were sent the identical first giving appeal by mail. Of alumni who did not respond to the initial request, one third then received a phone solicitation from a faculty member; one third received a phone solicitation from a student; and one third received a second written appeal. The number of gifts that resulted from each group was then compared with anticipated distribution of frequency of giving. The dollar amount of giving was not a factor in this study.
The data collected was subjected to a chi-square test to determine whether there was a statistically significant relationship between the experimental groups' number of gifts and the type of solicitation applied. With a calculated chi-square value of2.52 and 2 degrees of freedom, the probability was calculated as p = .28. Thus, the null hypothesis, that there was no significant relationship between the experimental treatment and the number of gifts resulting, was supported.
The conclusions drawn from these results included rejecting the alternative hypothesis, which stated there was a relationship between the type of solicitation applied and the number of gifts which resulted.
As a result of this investigation, the college increased it reliance on a second mailed solicitation as the standard follow up on the original solicitation, a recommendation was made to eliminate the annual phonathon staffed by student volunteers, and several prongs for additional research are recommended to further evaluate the effectiveness of various types of alumni solicitations.