Improving the design and conduct of aquatic toxicity studies with oils based on 20 years of CROSERF experience

Authors

WA Stubblefield, Oregon State University
M Barron, United States Environmental Protection Agency
G Bragin, ExxonMobil Biomedical Sciences
ME DeLorenzo, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)
B de Jourdan, Huntsman Marine Science Centre
B Echols, Environmental Toxicology Associates
DP French-McCay, RPS Group
P Jackman, Environment and Climate Change Canada
JR Loughery, Huntsman Marine Science Centre
TF Parkerton, EnviSci Consulting
D. Abigail Renegar, Nova Southeastern UniversityFollow
JL Rodriguez-Gil, International Institute for Sustainable Development Experimental Lakes Area (IISD-ELA)

Document Type

Article

Publication Title

Aquatic Toxicology

ISSN

1879-1514

Publication Date

8-2023

Keywords

CROSERF, Aquatic toxicity test methods, Aquatic toxicology

Abstract

Laboratory toxicity testing is a key tool used in oil spill science, spill effects assessment, and mitigation strategy decisions to minimize environmental impacts. A major consideration in oil toxicity testing is how to replicate real-world spill conditions, oil types, weathering states, receptor organisms, and modifying environmental factors under laboratory conditions. Oils and petroleum-derived products are comprised of thousands of compounds with different physicochemical and toxicological properties, and this leads to challenges in conducting and interpreting oil toxicity studies. Experimental methods used to mix oils with aqueous test media have been shown to influence the aqueous-phase hydrocarbon composition and concentrations, hydrocarbon phase distribution (i. e., dissolved phase versus in oil droplets), and the stability of oil:water solutions which, in turn, influence the bioavailability and toxicity of the oil containing media. Studies have shown that differences in experimental methods can lead to divergent test results. Therefore, it is imperative to standardize the methods used to prepare oil:water solutions in order to improve the realism and comparability of laboratory tests. The CROSERF methodology, originally published in 2005, was developed as a standardized method to prepare oil:water solutions for testing and evaluating dispersants and dispersed oil. However, it was found equally applicable for use in testing oil-derived petroleum substances. The goals of the current effort were to: (1) build upon two decades of experience to update existing CROSERF guidance for conducting aquatic toxicity tests and (2) to improve the design of laboratory toxicity studies for use in hazard evaluation and development of quantitative effects models that can then be applied in spill assessment. Key experimental design considerations discussed include species selection (standard vs field collected), test substance (single compound vs whole oil), exposure regime (static vs flow-through) and duration, exposure metrics, toxicity endpoints, and quality assurance and control.

DOI

10.1016/j.aquatox.2023.106579

Volume

261

First Page

106579

Comments

This work was supported through the Government of Canada’s Department of Fisheries and Oceans Multi-Partner Research Initiative.

© 2023 The Authors.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License.

NSUWorks Citation

WA Stubblefield, M Barron, G Bragin, ME DeLorenzo, B de Jourdan, B Echols, DP French-McCay, P Jackman, JR Loughery, TF Parkerton, D. Abigail Renegar, and JL Rodriguez-Gil. 2023. Improving the design and conduct of aquatic toxicity studies with oils based on 20 years of CROSERF experience .Aquatic Toxicology : 106579 . https://nsuworks.nova.edu/occ_facarticles/1359.