Chemistry and Physics Faculty Proceedings, Presentations, Speeches, Lectures

Presentation Date

10-9-2022

Document Type

Report

ORCID ID

0000-0001-8861-0898

Description

Since the Hunan Seafood Market (HSM) in Wuhan, China was first suggested as the source of the COVID-19 pandemic in late January 2020, debate has continued over the evidence supporting this claim. Here, we assess the evidence provided in support of zoonotic spillover at the HSM as the origin of human infection of SARS-CoV-2. We find that the datasets and analyses put forward in support of zoonosis are biased, and lack sufficient verifiable data to support this hypothesis. The earliest COVID-19 case at the HSM was not at or near a wildlife stall, the distribution of cases at the HSM is consistent with a Poisson point process model (randomly distributed) and the distribution of wildlife stalls and COVID-19 cases are consistent with independent Poisson point processes. No statistical correlation is found between cases and wildlife stall locations. The random distribution of cases and several isolated clusters is consistent with human-to-human transmission in shared areas such as eating areas, toilets and social gathering areas. Sampling bias is evident in specimen collection at the market, with over-sampling evident in the SW corner of the market relative to the rest of the market. Notwithstanding this bias, environmental positive PCR samples are more consistent with contamination by infected COVID-19 cases and aerosol spread from the HSM toilets, as compared with from wildlife stalls. Although proposed as the intermediate spillover host, raccoon dogs were unlikely to be linked with the outbreak, as they were sold in Wuhan in small numbers, and there is no epidemiological evidence indicating any infection of a raccoon dog, or any other wild or domestic animal, before or during the early pandemic, at any market elsewhere in Wuhan, or even in the rest of China. These considerations indicate that HSM was instead likely a superspreader location, with only tenuous evidence to support a zoonotic spillover there. Consequently, we conclude there is sufficient evidence to indicate the HSM as the source of the pandemic.

DOI

10.5281/zenodo.7169296

First Page

1

Last Page

45

Download

Share

COinS